Indiana Deputy Recounts Close Encounter with Bigfoot
Posted Saturday, August 29, 2026
By Squatchable.com staff
If you've spent any time digging into Bigfoot reports from the Midwest, you've probably heard whispers about a strange encounter in Yellowwood State Forest back in 2020. A father and his young daughter were out turkey hunting when they spotted something tall, gray, and decidedly not human moving through the trees. The story has circulated in Bigfoot circles for years, but a recent video I stumbled across on YouTube brings the whole thing to life in a way that's hard to shake.
The video, posted by the channel William's Horror Stories, tells the tale from the perspective of a fictional sheriff who responded to the call that day. And honestly? It's one of the more compelling dramatizations of a Bigfoot encounter I've come across in a while. The narrator, a 12-year veteran of the Brown County Sheriff's Department in Indiana, walks through the whole afternoon in a way that feels grounded and real, like you're sitting across from him at a diner while he tells you something he's never told anyone else.
What makes this one stand out is the detail. The sheriff describes the figure as at least seven feet tall, with broad shoulders, long arms hanging unusually low, and gray hair that looked more like coarse human hair than an animal's coat. He mentions the whooping sounds, the knocking, and the way the woods went dead silent right before the encounter. Anyone who's spent time reading encounter reports knows these are classic Bigfoot hallmarks, and they're woven into the story naturally.
There's also a moment that gave me chills. After the sheriff sees the figure and it runs off, he walks back to his patrol car and finds smudges on the window, handprints, but higher than his own shoulder. Whatever had been standing there was tall. Really tall. He locks the doors without even thinking about it, and you can almost feel the adrenaline through the screen.
The video does include a disclaimer noting that it's a work of fiction inspired by a real reported 2020 encounter in Yellowwood State Forest. The responding officer and dialogue are made up, but the location and the original sighting are based on actual accounts. That blend of real and imagined is what makes it so effective. It respects the original report while filling in the gaps in a way that feels authentic.
For those unfamiliar with Yellowwood State Forest, it's a roughly 23,000-acre stretch of hardwood forest in southern Indiana, full of ridges, hollows, and remote backcountry. It's the kind of place where Bigfoot reports have popped up for decades. Indiana isn't usually the first state people think of when they think of Sasquatch territory, but the Midwest has a long, quiet history of sightings, and Brown County in particular seems to come up more than its fair share of times.
The video is worth the watch if you're into atmospheric storytelling and you appreciate when someone takes a real report and treats it with the seriousness it deserves. It's not sensationalized, and it doesn't lean into cheap jump scares. It just tells the story the way a seasoned officer might if he finally decided to open up about the one call that stuck with him.
If you want to check it out, search for it on YouTube and give it a listen. It's the kind of story that stays with you, especially the part about the little girl saying, "It was looking at me." That line alone is enough to remind you why so many people take these encounters seriously.