Lost Idaho Boy Claims Bigfoot Carried Him 31 Miles Home
Posted Monday, July 13, 2026
By Squatchable.com staff
A former search and rescue officer from Idaho County just dropped what might be one of the most jaw-dropping firsthand Bigfoot accounts I've come across in a long time, and honestly, I had to share it with you right away.
The Forest Sentinel on YouTube recently posted a video featuring Merl Ostrander, a man who spent 19 years coordinating search and rescue operations in Idaho County, Idaho. He's 78 years old now, and he's finally talking about something that happened back in October of 1994 that he says ended his career. What he describes is the kind of story that makes your skin tingle, because it comes from a man with real credentials, real experience in the wilderness, and a sealed evidence box sitting in a courthouse in Grangeville that apparently backs up everything he's saying.
Here's the gist of what he shared. On October 8th, 1994, a 7-year-old boy named Toby Rener walked away from his father's elk camp on Meadow Creek, deep in the Selway-Bitterroot Wilderness. The kid was only 46 pounds, wearing a red Chicago Bulls stocking cap and Velcro sneakers, and he vanished into country that, as Ostrander puts it, "kills grown men in three." The father, Carl Rener, spent the entire night firing signal shots and screaming into the timber, getting nothing back but his own echo.
What followed was the largest search and rescue operation in the history of Idaho County. Thirty people in the field before noon, the Idaho Army National Guard sending a Huey out of Boise, the Civil Air Patrol flying grids above the drainage, and a bloodhound handler named Buck Tune driving in from Orofino with a dog called Sadie who had 11 live finds to her name. Volunteers kept showing up, loggers burning vacation days, ranch wives hauling casseroles up washboard roads. The whole valley quietly rearranged itself around one missing child.
Here's where it gets really interesting. Sadie scented off Toby's pillowcase at the camp and took the trail hard for about a quarter mile downstream, right past a single sneaker print one of the hasty teams had flagged on a sandbar. Then she stopped in the middle of the gravel, planted her hindquarters on the rocks, faced the timber on the far bank, and refused to move in any direction. Buck told Ostrander later that she wasn't confused. A confused hound circles and casts and whines. Sadie just sat there.
When they crossed the riffle to cast for scent on the far side, they found it. Pressed into black mud in a seep where skunk cabbage grows, about 30 feet up the opposite bank, was a barefoot human track. Seventeen and a half inches long. Seven inches across the ball. Toes splayed and clearly defined. Sunk two full inches deep, where Ostrander's own boot beside it sank only half an inch. The stride to the next partial measured 52 inches.
Now, Ostrander makes a point of laying out his credentials up front because he knows what he's about to say sounds impossible. He's cast hundreds of tracks. He knows bear, both species, in every gait. He knows what a boot looks like coming apart. And he knows a hoax when a print shows no pressure ridges. This track had pressure ridges. It had a mid-foot flex line. Whatever made it was walking heavy and headed uphill away from the creek.
For anyone who's spent time studying Sasquatch evidence, that mid-foot flex line is a detail that comes up again and again in credible track reports. Dr. Grover Krantz, the late physical anthropologist who spent decades studying Sasquatch evidence and actually had a plaster cast on his desk for years, identified that exact feature as one of the key anatomical signatures that distinguishes Sasquatch tracks from fakes or from any known hominid. The mid-foot flex line indicates a foot that rolls through the stride the way a large primate's foot does, not the rigid, flat-footed strike you'd see in a human or a hoaxer trying to fake depth with a carved impression. Pressure ridges around the edges of the print, where the soil actually displaced under weight, are another hallmark that researchers like Krantz, John Bindernagel, and the late René Dahinden all pointed to as evidence of a living, weight-bearing foot rather than a static cast pressed into the ground.
Ostrander did something in the next hour that he says he'll defend to his grave. He mixed plaster from the emergency kit, pulled the cast, wrapped it in a feed sack, locked it in his Bronco, and told the two searchers who'd seen it that they were keeping the find off the radio. Not hiding it, he says, sequestering it. A search is a machine built out of volunteers, and he didn't want the operation derailed by something nobody was ready to deal with.
Nine days after Toby vanished, on the morning of October 17th, the boy was found sitting on his own front porch outside Kooskia. Thirty-one miles of roadless timber from where he disappeared. Warm, fed, and asking his mother for pancakes. Ostrander says he wrote down what the tracks told him, wrote down what the boy told him, and then typed nine words that ended his career: "The boy states that a giant carried him home."
There's more to the story, too. Ostrander mentions a sealed evidence box in Grangeville that isn't only about the boy who came back. It's about another boy lost 26 years earlier who never did. He also drops the detail that every man who ordered him to stay quiet is now in the ground, which is why he's finally talking at 78 years old.
The Selway-Bitterroot Wilderness is over a million acres of granite ridges and cedar bottoms stacked clear to the Montana line, protected under the Wilderness Act of 1964. It's the kind of country where old growth cedar grows so thick the ground beneath it stays dusk at noon. If you're a researcher or just someone who loves these stories, the geography alone makes this one worth sitting with. Idaho County is bigger than the state of New Jersey, and most of it has never seen a road.
Honestly, this is the kind of account that doesn't come along often. A retired search and rescue commander with 19 years of experience, a plaster cast that apparently still exists in a sealed box, a bloodhound that refused to track past a certain point, and a 7-year-old boy who walked out of a million-acre wilderness after nine days with no explanation except the one he gave. You really need to hear Ostrander tell it himself. The video is worth every minute.