Illinois Bigfoot Sighting Forces Cheating Couple to Confess

Posted Sunday, August 30, 2026

By Squatchable.com staff

So there's this podcast episode that dropped recently, and honestly, it's one of those conversations that hits different when you're already deep into the world of cryptids and unexplained phenomena. The host, Diego, sits down with Gregory Fedora — and if that name rings a bell, it's because Fedora runs his own YouTube channel called The Fedora Files, where he digs into folklore, mythology, and all things that go bump in the night. The guy's a folklorist, author, and self-proclaimed cryptozoologist, and he's got a way of talking about these subjects that makes you feel like you're sitting around a campfire listening to someone who actually knows their stuff. One of the first things that caught my attention was Fedora's take on a Bigfoot sighting out of Illinois — the Murphysboro Mud Monster case, for those who are familiar with it. Now, this one's wild because it involves a couple who were, let's just say, in a compromising situation when they allegedly encountered a large, hairy, bipedal figure. And here's where it gets interesting: they were so shaken up by what they saw that they actually went to the police and reported it — which meant outing their affair to everyone, including their spouses. Think about that for a second. These people had every reason to stay quiet, but whatever they encountered was so terrifying that they were willing to blow up their entire personal lives just to get it off their chests. Fedora makes a really compelling point about cases like this — when witnesses have absolutely nothing to gain and everything to lose by coming forward, that's when you have to start taking the reports seriously. It's not like they were looking for fame or money. They were looking for someone to believe them. Fedora also touches on something that's been a theme in Sasquatch research for decades — the credibility factor. When police officers, military personnel, or people with professional reputations on the line report seeing something that shouldn't exist, it carries a different weight. These aren't folks looking for attention. They're risking their careers and their standing in their communities to share an experience that most people would just rather not talk about. And honestly, that pattern of credible witnesses coming forward is one of the strongest arguments for the existence of these beings that researchers have been pointing to for years. The conversation also drifts into Fedora's new book, "Blood and Beak: The South Mountain Terror," which is all about the Snallygaster — that legendary creature from South Mountain that predates Bigfoot sightings in that region by quite a bit. The Snallygaster has roots in German folklore, brought over by immigrants who settled in the Maryland and Pennsylvania area, and the stories have been passed down for generations. Fedora took all those scattered tales and wove them into narrative form, kind of like campfire stories you'd tell to scare the kids into going to bed. And if you've ever grown up hearing stories about creatures lurking in the woods, you know exactly the kind of vibe he's going for. There's also a fun tangent about a new podcast Fedora's launching called "Counter to Intelligence," where he and a skeptic friend debate various conspiracy theories. The twist? Fedora shows up with all the evidence and arguments, and his buddy has to try to debunk them on the spot — sometimes without even knowing the topic ahead of time. They've covered everything from the JFK assassination to the Moon Landing to, yes, Bigfoot. It's a neat concept because it forces both sides to actually engage with the evidence instead of just dismissing it. What really makes this episode worth your time, though, is Fedora's genuine passion for the subject. He's not some guy reading off a script — he's someone who's spent years researching these phenomena, talking to witnesses, and digging through historical records. His grandfather apparently had some wild stories from 1920s Milwaukee involving rival mafia gangs, which is a whole other rabbit hole, but it speaks to that tradition of oral storytelling that keeps these legends alive. If you're into cryptids, folklore, or just enjoy hearing someone talk about the unexplained with real enthusiasm, this one's definitely worth checking out. Fedora brings a unique perspective as both a researcher and a storyteller, and the conversation flows naturally in a way that makes you feel like you're just hanging out with someone who really loves this stuff.